Baseball’s Payroll Disparity Problem Explained. The Case for a Salary Cap and Floor
MLB’s Executive Vice President of Baseball Operations, Morgan Sword, explains why the league is proposing a salary cap, a salary floor, and equal sharing of media revenue in its collective bargaining agreement (CBA) negotiations with the MLB Players Association, and what MLB says the proposal would mean for fans and players. He lays out MLB’s case that baseball’s payroll gap, the widest in major U.S. sports, gives big-market teams a lasting edge, and that sharing media revenue would let the league address local TV blackouts.
Key points from MLB’s case:
● Payroll gap: MLB says the difference between the top- and bottom-spending clubs is $446 million. Every other major U.S. sports league has both a salary cap and a floor.
● Does payroll buy wins? Since 1998, the top five payroll teams averaged 89 wins per season vs. 74 for the bottom five, per MLB.
● Postseason: Over the last decade, MLB says large-market teams made up 64% of postseason teams and 90% of World Series champions.
● Free agency: MLB says the top four clubs spent more on free agents during this CBA than the bottom 22 clubs combined.
● The proposal: a 50/50 revenue split between teams and players; a salary cap and floor (MLB says 12 teams would spend more and 8 less); and equal sharing of media revenue, which MLB says would allow it to address local blackouts.
● Would Major League players earn less? The short answer is no. Under MLB’s proposal, Major League players would receive 50% of all baseball revenue. The proposal also includes increases to the minimum salary, earlier free agency, and elimination of the qualifying offer. MLB says Major League players’ total compensation would rise, and that unlike other leagues that adopted a cap, it is not asking players to take pay cuts.
● For fans: MLB argues the system would help every fan base believe its team can compete, rather than expecting its favorite players to eventually leave for larger markets, and cites an independent poll showing 79% of baseball fans support a salary cap and floor.
Chapters:
0:00 Morgan Sword on MLB’s CBA proposal
0:35 What do baseball fans want fixed? Blackouts and fairness
0:50 How big is baseball’s payroll gap?
1:45 Does spending more buy wins in baseball?
2:37 Why do big-market teams dominate the postseason?
3:06 What is MLB proposing? Cap, floor, and a 50/50 split
3:33 How would shared media revenue help address local blackouts?
4:10 Why pair a salary cap with a salary floor?
4:22 Would players earn less under a salary cap?
4:47 What does this mean for fans and their favorite players?
Recorded November 2026. Read MLB’s full proposal: https://www.mlb.com/news/mlb-proposed-salary-cap-floor-system
Don’t forget to subscribe! https://www.youtube.com/mlb
Follow us elsewhere too:
Twitter: https://twitter.com/MLB
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/mlb/
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/mlb
TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@mlb
Visit our site for all baseball news, stats and scores! https://www.mlb.com/
